All Shorts Guides

Shorts Getting Few Comments

Comments in Shorts don’t appear “by themselves” — they show up when it’s easy for the viewer to answer. If you end the video with a generic “what do you think?” or with nothing at all, people will simply swipe away even if the Short was useful. In this guide: practical engagement techniques — choices, short constrained questions, “two positions”, mini tasks, and gentle provocation without toxicity.

Create Video for Free

Telegram bot will open — build a video in a minute and instantly test edits.

Why there are few comments

Commenting is effort. For a viewer to do it in the feed, three conditions matter:

It’s clear what to write. The question isn’t too broad and isn’t too hard.
There’s a reason to answer. You asked for an opinion, a choice, or experience — and it’s connected to the video.
There’s time. The last 1–2 seconds leave space: the thought is closed and the viewer can “react”.

If comments matter to you, treat the ending as carefully as the hook.

Engagement techniques: choice, a constrained question, “two positions”, a mini task

1) A/B choice (the simplest format)

“Which hook is better: A or B? Comment A/B.”
“Would you make this 20 seconds or 35? Comment 20/35.”
“What matters more at the start: result or mistake? 1/2.”

2) A constrained question (not “what do you think?”)

“At what second would you swipe? 1–3 / 4–7 / later.”
“What’s harder: the hook or the ending? One word.”
“Which mistake happens more often for you: pace or text? pace/text.”

3) A mini task

“Comment your niche — I’ll suggest 3 angles for Shorts.”
“Drop one topic — I’ll propose 2 hook variants.”
“Comment ‘plan’ if you want a 10‑video template.”

4) Two positions (softly, without toxicity)

The point is to show two normal options and ask people to choose. It sparks discussion without drama.

“Better: ‘3 mistakes’ or ‘2 steps’? Which is clearer to you?”
“A question‑hook or a result‑hook? Which do you watch more often?”
“Speak fast or use more pauses? What feels more comfortable?”

Phrase examples for different formats (education / cases / opinions)

Education: “Which checklist point fails for you most often? 1/2/3.”
Cases: “How long does it take you to edit one Short? 10/30/60 minutes?”
Opinions: “Agree: greetings in Shorts are almost always a minus? yes/no.”
Continuation: “Want part 2? Comment ‘2’ and I’ll continue.”

Important: the question must be connected to the video. If the Short is about pace but you end with “what topics should I film?” — it breaks the logic.

Mistakes that kill discussion

A too broad question. “What do you think?” — it’s unclear what to answer.
Several questions in a row. The viewer doesn’t choose and writes nothing.
Toxic provocation. It may bring comments, but often reduces trust and retention.
Asking at the start. Value first, then a question — otherwise people don’t engage.

A checklist for a good question (that people actually answer)

Short. One question, one task.
Easy to answer. A/B, a number, one word — not an essay.
Connected to the video. Continues the thought instead of changing the topic.
Has context. The viewer understands why you’re asking.
Has a pause. Leave 1–2 seconds at the end so the viewer can react.

If you want comment growth, replying matters too: the first 10–20 replies from the creator often “kickstart” the thread.

Pinned comment ideas (to continue the topic)

A pinned comment helps “finish” the discussion: the viewer reads it and understands what exactly to write. A few options:

A/B: “Which variant do you prefer — A or B? Comment the letter.”
Number: “At what second do you usually swipe? 1–2 / 3–5 / later.”
Niche: “Comment your niche — I’ll suggest 2 ideas for the next Short.”
Continuation: “Want part 2? Comment ‘2’ and I’ll break down the next step.”

The key is not trying to “stuff everything in”. One video = one reason to comment.

To make the pin work better, actively reply in the first 1–2 hours after publishing: people see you’re in the dialog and comment more willingly.

If you want a quick test: publish 3 Shorts in a row on the same topic, but with different question formats (A/B, number, mini task). You’ll see what engagement type works for your audience — without guessing.

After a week of tests you’ll have a clear conclusion which endings trigger replies more often.

Lock in the best format and repeat it.

How to reply to comments so you get more comments

Reply with a question. “What niche are you in?” helps continue the dialog.
Collect topics. “Ok, I’ll shoot a continuation about endings — comment what exactly breaks.”
Give mini value. One short tip in a reply = more trust and more discussion.
Keep one format. When viewers know you reply regularly, they comment more willingly.

Make the answer as easy as possible

If you want more comments, don’t ask “write what you think”. Give an answer format: one word, a choice of two, a number (1/2/3). And ask a question that matches the topic of the video, not a generic one. Example: “What drops more often for you: the start or the middle? Comment: start/middle.” This reduces effort for the viewer and noticeably increases replies — especially if you pin the question in the comments.

How to test changes faster

Comments are easy to test through the ending: the same Short, but different questions. Make 2–3 ending versions (A/B choice, a mini task, “two positions”) and compare where viewers write more often. If assembling a version takes minutes, not hours, you quickly find the wording that “starts” discussion — without stress and guessing.

The easiest way to raise reactions is by testing the ending: two variants of a question/CTA in the last seconds and one next step. In the AdShorts AI Telegram bot you can quickly rebuild a Short with a different ending/on‑screen text and see what brings more likes and comments.